The top story on the CBC News website this evening is “Net Neutrality doesn’t exist, CRTC told.”
Laugh or cry?
Internet congestion is inevitable and net neutrality does not exist, Canada’s internet regulator was told Monday at hearings on how internet providers control and manage internet traffic and speed.
But here’s the best part:
Congestion is a natural occurrence on the internet, partly due to unexpected events such as Michael Jackson’s death, said Don Bowman, chief technology officer for the network technology company Sandvine Inc.
Got that? It is Michael Jackson’s fault that you are being throttled! Hee.
According to the same CBC coverage, Bowman also asserts that deep packet inspection is necessary in order to keep VOIP from breaking up due to congestion. I’m no ISP, but I have a hunch there are other options here…for example deploying other “shaping” technologies that don’t invade customer privacy, or the radical path of increasing available bandwidth.(On this note, I am quite intrigued by Scott Stevens’ suggestion “that some internet traffic management could be carried out by customers themselves rather than the ISPs” and interested in how that could work!)
What’s disturbing is that Bowman is not only acting as a CTO but speaking at this CRTC hearing, apparently without knowing that net neutrality is. He is quoted as saying:
“In times of congestion, an unmanaged network is not a neutral network,” he said. “Inequalities in application design and user behaviour mean that an unmanaged network inherently favours certain applications and their users.”
Actually…an “unmanaged” network *is* a neutral network. That’s pretty much the defninition, if by unmanaged you mean the ISP is not allowed to tamper with or discriminate among the content flowing across their lines. A neutral network is a highway with no toll roads, no right to pull you over to see if you have pornography or the Little Red Book in your backpack in the passenger seat, and no ability to say that Hondas get a fast lane but Fords have to take the slow lane.
I don’t get how this guy can say net neutrality doesn’t exist. However, if it works for him, I’m going to start declaring things I find either personally distasteful or bad for my wallet nonexistant. Like…paying rent. Rent payments definitely do not exist, you know. They are but flights of fancy which we should no longer indulge. Also torture — It doesn’t exist anymore. And those people who say “liberry” and “I could care less” — totally fictional, you know.
Figments of the imagination.